Tuthill House at the Mill Restaurant expertly prepares homemade, American cuisine featuring prime steaks, grass-fed beef, seafood, and pasta in a historic 1788 grist mill. Tuthill House at the Mill Restaurant & Tavern’s menu is inspired by American country cooking, featuring fresh, local artisan products and ingredients of the Hudson Valley.

Located in Gardiner, NY, the Tuthilltown Gristmill is the oldest continuously operated water powered gristmill in New York State and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The original Gristmill structure was constructed in 1788 by 18 year old Selah Tuthill and used an overshot wheel to power the grinding stones. It is one of three mills which have operated on the Shawangunkill over the past 300 years. During the last two centuries, the mill has undergone a series of upgrades and additions. It is located on the old Albany Post Road, which originally served as the main route from New York to the Capitol for 190 years.


Selections from the Tuthill House at the Mill Restaurant & Tavern Menu:

  • POACHED SHRIMP – Half Moon Gin Poached Shrimp, House-made Bloody Mary
  • CRISPY MARINATED TOFU – Coconut Green Curry Sauce, Pineapple, Cilantro, Lime
  • WILD MUSHROOM FLATBREAD – Carrot Puree, Goat Cheese, Wild Mushrooms, Arugula, Tarragon Vinaigrette, Grilled Crust
  • USDA PRIME HOUSE CUT-DRY AGED STEAKS – All steaks are served with potato and choice of vegetable or salad
  • SWEET & SPICY BRAISED EGGPLANT – Coconut Ginger Basmati Rice, Peppers, Fresh Herbs & Crushed Peanuts
  • PAN-SEARED DUCK BREAST – Local Duck, Warm Napa Cabbage Salad, Sweet Thai Vinaigrette
  • CHORIZO BURGER – House-Made Chorizo, Sunny Side Up Farm Fresh Egg, NY Cheddar Cheese & Pickled Jalapeño Mournet
  • DARK CHOCOLATE TORTE – Dark Belgian Chocolate, Graham Cracker Crust, Strawberry Coulis, Vanilla Bean Whipped Cream
  • ORANGE BLOSSOM & HONEY PANNA COTTA – Tahitian Vanilla Bean Whipped Cream