McGillicuddy’s, affectionately called “Cuddy’s,” is a popular and longstanding tap house and family restaurant nestled right in downtown New Paltz. Known for its lively college-town atmosphere, it creates a warm and inviting space that both locals and visitors love. During the day, it’s the perfect spot for laid-back, casual meals with friends and family, while in the evening, it turns into a lively bar full of music, entertainment, and good vibes, making every visit special.
The menu features classic American pub favorites with hearty portions that satisfy. Known for having the “Best Wings in the Hudson Valley,” the wings are a must-try, available in over twenty tasty sauces like Honey Buffalo and Garlic Parmesan. Popular dishes include the irresistible Irish Nachos on crispy waffle fries, hearty Irish Potato Soup, and the flavorful Chicken Godfather sandwich. The menu also offers vegetarian options like the Black Bean Burger and the Portobello Mushroom Swiss Burger, and gluten-free buns are available for an extra charge, so everyone can enjoy a fantastic meal in a lively, upbeat setting.
View this profile on Instagram
McGillicuddy’s really comes alive late at night, with a fun, energetic vibe, and stays open until 4:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays. It hosts a bunch of lively events like Poker nights, Well Buckets, Trivia, Karaoke, Late-night DJs with dancing, and Happy Hour.
The staff is generally friendly, welcoming, and quick to serve, though the experience can sometimes vary if it’s really busy. Most people say the staff is super friendly and helpful, often describing them as “enthusiastic,” “attentive,” and “sweethearts.” They’re especially great with families—hostesses often bring out a treasure chest full of toys for kids to pick a prize, keeping little ones happily entertained while they wait for their food. The bartenders are known for their skill, whether it’s pouring a perfect Guinness or mixing up fantastic cocktails.
Map/Directions/Reviews
Ad
Share this!
04/23/26