Pizza Heaven – Home Of The GIANT SLICE In New Windsor

Pizza Heaven is a well-established Italian restaurant located in New Windsor, NY. Renowned as the “Home of the Giant Slice,” this popular eatery has become a staple in the community. Since its founding in 1993, this family-owned pizzeria has proudly served generations of customers, earning a reputation for its generous, large New York-style pizza and comforting homemade Italian dishes. Over the past three decades, Pizza Heaven has cultivated a loyal following by consistently offering delicious food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like a second home.

The menu highlights high-quality ingredients and features flavors reminiscent of home cooking. Their signature dish is a large single slice of pizza, often described as equivalent to 2.5 regular slices. Popular choices among customers include the White Pizza, Taco Pizza—which is widely celebrated as a local favorite—and Buffalo Chicken. Beyond pizza, the menu also includes delicious pepperoni rolls and flavorful chicken dishes.

This pizza place offers a relaxed, welcoming, family-friendly environment where guests can enjoy a comfortable and casual dining experience. Visitors often praise the generous portion sizes, the friendly and attentive staff, and the distinctive “NYC-style” crust that sets their pizzas apart. The pizzeria has also been recognized for its quality, earning the title of Orange County’s top pizzeria at one point.

View the Pizza Heaven menu.
View the Pizza Heaven Gallery.