Smith Bros. Pizza is a popular local spot in Poughkeepsie, NY, known for its bold, thin-crust, bar-style pizzas. Situated near the waterfront, it offers a casual counter-service setup with about 20 seats.
The menu features unique flavor combinations, and substitutions are generally not permitted to preserve the intended flavor profiles. The atmosphere is relaxed, modern, and stylish, emphasizing counter service over traditional sit-down dining. The space is described as a “clean, modern environment” that feels fresh and welcoming. It’s a small, cozy place with roughly 20 seats for dine-in customers.
Inside, high ceilings and large windows make the space feel open and airy. Customers often mention a “fun vibe” with good music, making it a popular spot to enjoy a meal. There is no waitstaff; orders are placed at the counter where staff prepare the food. Known for quick service, it’s ideal for a quick bite or solo dining.
Despite its bar-style setting, it’s considered family-friendly. Smith Bros. Pizza also serves alcohol and has an onsite bar area, mainly functioning as a counter-service pizzeria rather than a full-service tavern. It offers beer and wine to complement its thin-crust, bar-style pizzas. The onsite bar provides a casual space to enjoy a drink while waiting or eating, all within a clean, modern interior that maintains the casual vibe, with no table service—orders are placed at the counter.
Smith Bros. Pizza is situated right by the water, providing scenic views of the Hudson River and the Mid-Hudson Bridge.
Selections From Smith Bros. Pizza Menu
The Oh-Gee Pizza
Simple yet so satisfying, with their signature tomato sauce and blend of cheeses. Finished with a generous amount of Romano, garlic, oregano spice, olive oil, and fresh basil leaves.
Honey Hot Pepperoni
Their signature tomato sauce and cheese blend, topped with plenty of crispy, spicy cup and char pepperoni. Finished with a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey for a sweet and spicy kick.
The Sailor Man Pizza
Creamy garlic sauce serves as the base, topped with their cheese blend, earthy goat cheese, and sautéed mixed mushrooms. Fresh spinach leaves add a touch of green, and candied walnuts provide a sweet, crunchy finish.
Meat Lover’s Pizza
A hearty combination of their signature sauce and cheese blend, topped with cup and char pepperoni, seasoned ground pork, meatballs, and crispy bacon. Finished with spicy jalapeños for a perfect balance of meaty richness and heat.
Truffle Shuffle Pizza
Creamy ricotta with truffles and gooey mozzarella lay the foundation, topped with savory sautéed mushrooms for an earthy kick. Fresh arugula adds a peppery crunch, and it’s all tied together with a drizzle of sweet, tangy balsamic reduction. Each order comes with two fun-size Baby Ruth candy bars—if you know, you know.
Grandma Pizza
A thin Sicilian-style pizza topped with their homemade crushed tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh garlic, and Romano Cheese
Map/Directions/Reviews
Ad
Share this!
022626