Pickled Pig Deli is an unpretentious family-owned and operated deli and cafe in New Paltz, NY, that recently took over the longtime Russo’s Italian Deli location. Known for its “huge” sandwiches, house-made pickles, and a casual, friendly atmosphere that complements its well-crafted selection.
The menu features a mix of classic deli fare and unique house specialties, including smash burgers, cold subs with Boar’s Head meats, and specialty hot sandwiches. Popular items include the Meatball Parm Sub, Big Philly Cheesesteak, and the “My Cousin Luca” (a carryover from the previous deli). A daily-rotating hot lunch is served from a fresh steam table, featuring items like homemade meatloaf. Large, soft-baked cookies (such as Oreo) and homemade potato salad are also well-known.
Described as clean, comfortable, and casual, the atmosphere at Pickled Pig Deli has a family-style vibe. Since taking over the location, the owners have gradually updated the space with fresh touches, including light sage-colored paint, new shiplap siding, and upgraded lighting to create a brighter “vibe.” Seven indoor tables and a counter seating four provide dining options. The indoor space is often described by reviewers as “cute” and “homey.” A small patio with three tables, often equipped with four red chairs, allows guests to dine while observing foot traffic on Main Street. Outdoor seating, which is openly dog-friendly, makes it a popular spot for locals walking their pets.
Frequent praise is given to staff and owners for their outgoing and attentive service, with many customers noting that their names are remembered. Orders are delivered promptly and accurately. The business is recognized as LGBTQ+-friendly and features gender-neutral restrooms. Guests can enjoy free Wi-Fi while dining to stay connected.
Selections From The Pickled Pig Deli Menu
- Eggplant Delight – Breaded eggplant, pesto, balsamic glaze, roasted red peppers, and fresh mozzarella.
- Messy Russian – Grilled and roasted beef with melted cheddar, BBQ sauce, Russian dressing, topped with coleslaw.
- Chicken Parm Special w/Roni – Breaded chicken, mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce, topped with grilled pepperoni.
- Kickin Philly Sub – Pepper, onions, jalapeños, mozzarella sticks, Philly meat, and chipotle mayo.
- Luca Sandwich – Breaded chicken, provolone cheese, lettuce, red onion, oil, vinegar, mayo, and prosciutto.
- The Raab – Breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella, pesto, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze, and broccoli Rabe.
- Tasty Beef – Roast beef, Swiss cheese, balsamic caramelized onions, horseradish mayo, on a toasted garlic roll( this meat is not grilled).
- Beef and Brie – Grilled roast beef, melted brie cheese, bread butter pickles, and garlic aioli.
- Meatball Parm – Homemade meatballs, mozzarella, and marinara sauce.
Map/Directions/Reviews
Ad
Share this!
031026