Frank’s Fresh Pickling is a family-run Italian-style deli that has become a favorite among both residents and visitors for its delicious sandwiches and house-made pickled goods. Opened in 2021 by Frank Cardella, a passionate food lover with a knack for flavors, the shop has quickly built a reputation as a community staple where quality and friendliness shine through.

At Frank’s, customers can not only enjoy a wide selection of freshly made sandwiches and paninis—each crafted with care and creativity—but can also take home jars of the shop’s signature pickled items. These include tangy pickled onions, crunchy radishes, traditional sauerkraut, flavorful relishes, and an assortment of hot sauces and gourmet jams. Each jar is a little taste of Frank’s dedication to quality.

The menu features inventive, flavorful deli sandwiches that regularly earn high praise. One of the standout favorites is the Cubano—packed with layers of savory ham, tangy dill pickles, and tender house-made roast pork—delighting customers with every bite.

Although the space itself is cozy and small, seating is limited, the warmth and friendliness of the staff make every visit feel like coming home. The shop is often bustling, especially with regulars who swear by the quality of the sandwiches and the exceptional house-made pickled treats. Many visitors describe Frank’s as a hidden gem—a place where you can enjoy some of the best sandwiches in the Hudson Valley area and discover unique pickled goods that keep you coming back.

All in all, Frank’s Fresh Pickling Co. is a delightful culinary spot that combines great food with warm community spirit, making it a must-visit destination for anyone exploring New Paltz.

Map/Directions/Reviews

For privacy reasons Google Maps needs your permission to be loaded. For more details, please see our Privacy Policy.

Selections From Frank’s Fresh Pickling:

  • Pickles – Habanero Garlic Dill – Classic garlic dill, trying to play it spicy. This dill is on the scoville scale.
  • Pickles – Kosher Dill – Classic garlic dill. Can’t go wrong with a classic!
  • Pickles – Bread & Butter – These bread and butters are going to be our bread-and-butter. They are so unique and delicious. Nothing but all natural ingredients with no added anything yucky.
  • Hot Sauce – Roasted Jalapeno – What’s better than a roasted pepper? A hot roasted pepper and hot sauce.
  • Hot Sauce – Red Habanero – Bright Habanero punch, deep garlic flavor with an acid kick!
  • Hot Sauce – Poblano Thai Dragon – Rich bold flavor. Slight karate kick.
  • Jam – Blueberry Peach – An under note of peach gives this blueberry jam just the right amount of deliciousness. Homemade, all-natural… Blueberries, peaches and sugar.
  • Jam – Jalapeno – Kick it up a notch with this jalapeno jam. Delicious with cream cheese and crackers or however you like to eat your spicy stuff! Peppers and all natural sugar!
  • Jam – Cherry – Nothing but fresh cherries, sugar, and a squeeze of lemon juice. This homemade jam is all natural!
  • Pickled Radishes – Korean style pickled radish. Goes well with Korean BBQ, Braised pork and all those gnarly noms.
  • Marinated Sweet Bells – Mini sweet bell peppers marinated in sweet cider vinaigrette with a hint of clove.
  • Balsamic Sweet Beets – This unique recipe is earthy crisp and sweet and goes great on salads, in wraps or out of the jar! Use the vinegar as a marinade when you add some olive oil or as a dressing.
  • Sauerkraut – Homemade and so good. Your hot dogs and Reubens will thank you!
  • Marinara Sauce – 32 ounces of homemade on the stove for hours momma style goodness.

View all of the Frank’s Fresh Pickling products.

View the sandwich menu.

For privacy reasons YouTube needs your permission to be loaded. For more details, please see our Privacy Policy.





100225